Custom security filtering in Solr

Custom security filtering in Solr by Erik Hatcher

Yonik recently wrote about “Advanced Filter Caching in Solr” where he talked about expensive and custom filters; it was left as an exercise to the reader on the implementation details. In this post, I’m going to provide a concrete example of custom post filtering for the case of filtering documents based on access control lists.

Recap of Solr’s filtering and caching

First let’s review Solr’s filtering and caching capabilities. Queries to Solr involve a full-text, relevancy scored, query (the infamous q parameter). As users navigate they will browse into facets. The search application generates filter query (fq) parameters for faceted navigation (eg. fq=color:red, as in the article referenced above). The filter queries are not involved in document scoring, serving only to reduce the search space. Solr sports a filter cache, caching the document sets of each unique filter query. These document sets are generated in advance, cached, and reduce the documents considered by the main query. Caching can be turned off on a per-filter basis; when filters are not cached, they are used in parallel to the main query to “leap frog” to documents for consideration, and a cost can be associated with each filter in order to prioritize the leap-frogging (smallest set first would minimize documents being considered for matching).

Post filtering

Even without caching, filter sets default to generate in advance. In some cases it can be extremely expensive and prohibitive to generate a filter set. One example of this is with access control filtering that needs to take the users query context into account in order to know which documents are allowed to be returned or not. Ideally only matching documents, documents that match the query and straightforward filters, should be evaluated for security access control. It’s wasteful to evaluate any other documents that wouldn’t otherwise match anyway. So let’s run through an example… a contrived example for the sake of showing how Solr’s post filtering works.

Good examples but also heed the author’s warning to use the techniques in this article when necessary. Some times simple solutions are the best. Like using the network authentication layer to prevent unauthorized users from seeing the Solr application at all. No muss, no fuss.

Comments are closed.