I pointed out in Lions, Tigers, and Lies! Oh My! that Bruce Schneier‘s concerns over the potential for hackers faking documents to be leaked pales beside the mis-information distributed by government.
Executive Summary of Review of the Unauthorized Disclosures of Former National Security Agency Contractor Edward Snowden (their title, not mine), is a case in point.
Barton Gellman in The House Intelligence Committee’s Terrible, Horrible, Very Bad Snowden Report leaves no doubt the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) report is a sack of lies.
Not mistakes, not exaggerations, not simply misleading, but actual, factual lies.
For example:
…
Since I’m on record claiming the report is dishonest, let’s skip straight to the fourth section. That’s the one that describes Snowden as “a serial exaggerator and fabricator,” with “a pattern of intentional lying.” Here is the evidence adduced for that finding, in its entirety.…
“He claimed to have obtained a high school degree equivalent when in fact he never did.”
I do not know how the committee could get this one wrong in good faith. According to the official Maryland State Department of Education test report, which I have reviewed, Snowden sat for the high school equivalency test on May 4, 2004. He needed a score of 2250 to pass. He scored 3550. His Diploma No. 269403 was dated June 2, 2004, the same month he would have graduated had he returned to Arundel High School after losing his sophomore year to mononucleosis. In the interim, he took courses at Anne Arundel Community College.
…
See Gellman’s post for more examples.
All twenty-two members of the HPSCI signed the report. To save you time in the future, here’s a listing of the members of Congress who agreed to report these lies:
Republicans
- Mike Conaway – 11th District of Texas
- Joe Heck – 3rd District of Nevada
- Ileana Ros-Lehtinen – 27th District of Florida
- Peter King – 2nd District of New York
- Frank LoBiondo – 2nd District of New Jersey
- Devin Nunes, Chairman – 22nd District of California
- Jeff Miller – 1st District of Florida
- Mike Pompeo – 4th District of Kansas
- Tom Rooney – 17th District of Florida
- Chris Stewart – 2nd District of Utah
- Michael Turner – 10th District of Ohio
- Brad Wenstrup – 2nd District of Ohio
- Lynn Westmoreland – 3rd District of Georgia
Democrats
- Andre Carson – 7th District of Indiana
- Joaquin Castro – 20th District of Texas
- Jim Himes – 4th District of Connecticut
- Patrick Murphy – 18th District of Florida
- Mike Quigley – 5th District of Illinois
- Adam Schiff, Ranking Member – 28th District of California
- Terri Sewell – 7th District of Alabama
- Jackie Speier – 14th District of California
- Eric Swalwell – 15th District of California
I sorted each group in to alphabetical order. The original listings were in an order that no doubt makes sense to fellow rodents but not to the casual reader.
That’s twenty-two members of Congress who are willing to distribute known falsehoods.
Does anyone have an equivalent list of hackers?