New report details how Israeli soldiers killed civilians in Gaza: “There were no rules” by William Booth.
From the post:
On Monday, an organization of Israeli soldiers known as “Breaking the Silence” released a report containing testimonies from more than 60 officers and soldiers from the Israel Defense Forces who served during the 50-day war against Hamas militants last summer in the Gaza Strip.
…
An Israel Defense Forces spokesman declined to respond to details in the report, saying Breaking the Silence refuses to share information with the IDF “in a manner which would allow a proper response, and if required, investigation.” The spokesman added that “contrary to their claims, this organization does not act with the intention of correcting any wrongdoings they allegedly uncovered.”
The soldiers who testified received guarantees of anonymity from Breaking the Silence. The 240-page book in English can be found online here.
…
Don’t you like the IDF response:
in a manner which would allow a proper response, and if required, investigation.
Of course, not anonymous but with names and who was with you (other people that could be pressured), attendant damage to your career or future job prospects, etc.
Not to single out the IDF for criticism. Virtually the same response has been given by the U.S. military for a variety of issues.
Governments and their military services fear transparency because transparency could lead to accountability. Civilians should not second-guess decisions made in the heat of battle by combat troops. Their leaders, who made decisions for political gain, should certainly be called to account.